| |
 |
|
 |
From our current position in history it is difficult to completely visualize the time of the Civil War. The United States was young, and in many ways still an experiment in nation building. The Constitution specifically allowed states the decision to "drop out and go their own way" even though this had never been tested. There was a great deal of stress over the issue of slavery and Congress had unsuccessfully tried to find a compromises to keep peace among the different points of view.
In other ways the Country was very different. There were only 34 states and expansion of the western territory was a major issue. (When you read about the armies operating in the "western theatre" they are talking about Arkansas, Mississippi, Texas, and Louisiana, not California). We were an agrarian society very dependent on farms and farm labor. Families were large and travel was difficult. Often one had to chose between letting your family starve and serving in the military. For the most part, there was no large standing army. The lack of a standing army was particularly acute in the South since one had to be formed after the split from the Union.
The list of differences goes on and on. But what was not different was loyalty, patriotism, and the enthusiasm for war that closely follows significant political events. If your family had any ties in the southern states during 1860, then it was almost impossible to avoid military service. It has been estimated that the Confederacy mobilized as many as 80% of the available male population of fighting age during the war. The previously mentioned fear of slave uprisings kept many men with large farms at home in the South, so the armies were mainly comprised of everyday working men.
Our families were all in the South during the early part of the 1800s, so it follows that we will have large numbers of men who participated as soldiers. In fact we have identified almost 500 men from our records who served in one capacity or another. Most were privates in some fighting unit, but that would have been normal for the era. |
 |
Accepting military service during the Civil War would have given anyone more than a few moments of reluctance. Shortly after the war started and the battlefield casualty figures started to come in the realization of what service meant would have struck home. When men volunteered for service they did so out of loyalty for family and state and certainly not for personal glory. Looking through the lens of history, this was a war fought with modern fire power and antiquated tactics.
In the 1860s armies were still raised on the local level and amalgamated into larger fighting forces. Units could be personally funded and officers often put in place because of personal charisma or wealth, not leadership skills. Often this meant that relatives and neighbors fought side-by-side. Families, friends, and neighbors often suffered unimaginable losses when a local unit was involved in a major battle.
Today we become upset at the loss of a single life, but during the Civil War losses were staggering, perhaps as high as 700,000. Remember that everyone lost on both sides was eventually a loss for our nation. Take a look at the approximate losses from just ten major battles and how short the duration of fighting: |
Battle (Days) |
Union |
Confederate |
Gettysburg 1863 (3) |
23,000 |
28,000 |
Chickamauga 1862 (2) |
16,000 |
18,000 |
Chancellorsville 1863 (4) |
17,000 |
13,000 |
Spotsylvania 1864 (12) |
18,000 |
9,000 |
Antietam 1862 (1) |
12,000 |
14,000 |
Wilderness 1864 (4) |
18,000 |
8,000 |
2nd Manassas 1862 (2) |
16,000 |
9,000 |
Stone's River 1862 (1) |
13,000 |
12,000 |
Shiloh 1862 (2) |
13,000 |
10,000 |
Fort Donelson 1862 (4) |
3,000 |
17,000 |
Total |
149,000 |
138,000 |
|
Just these battles lasting approximately thirty-five days produced about 287,000 casualties. If your stomach did not churn more than a little when you got a draft notice then one needed to be checked mentally. |
|
|
|
 |
When we think about wars in the history of our Country and the manpower needed to fight, the draft process almost always comes to mind. In the beginning of the Civil War the draft was not needed because of the volume of volunteers on both sides of the conflict.
Several things became apparent after 1861 that perhaps we can only see through the lens of history.
- The conflict was not going to end quickly and the original enlistees would not provide enough manpower to conduct the war
- Losses were going to be on a scale heretofore unimaginable (in the North perhaps as high as 8% and in the South as high as 18% of all men of fighting age)
- This could easily evolve into a war of attrition, giving the North a decided advantage
- In the South men would need to enlist for the term of the war if they were to have enough manpower to put armies in the field
- The draft process was both inefficient and ineffective
In the North, states were assigned quotas for fighting units. Often large numbers were excluded for health reasons or just did not report. Another issue was the ability to hire a "substitute" to serve in one's place. It was also possible to pay a fee to the Government as an election to not serve. Often, the threat of the draft seemed to serve as enough of a deterrent to fill the ranks, but the draft was as unpopular then as in all wars.
In the South the issues were similar, but in some ways different. The South there were fewer men of military service age, so more had to serve on a percentage basis. Most men either enlisted for the duration of the war, or had their volunteer or draft status revoked and had to serve for the whole war. In the South there was another difference created by the slave society. In the early part of the war men who had farms with large slave populations were exempt from military service since it was felt that they were needed at home to prevent an uprising. |
 |
Any time someone talks about the "good old days" they certainly are not speaking about the antebellum United States. Just a few things to consider:
- Sanitation was poorly understood and certainly not considered important
- Medical care was barbaric by current standards and many wounds were treated by amputation
- Food was scarce, especially in the South
- Horses were the primary mode of transportation, meaning horse manure was everywhere
- Few if any paved roads
- No air conditioning and little refrigeration
- No pest control
- There was a high rate of infant mortality
- The primary occupation was that of farmer, meaning hard work and few rewards
- Families were very large to support farms, but many women died in childbirth
Need we say more? |
| |
|
|
|